East Village Pizza Menu — NYC Slices, Whole Pies & More

Looking for the best pizza menu in Manhattan? East Village Pizza offers classic New York slices, whole pies, and specialty pizzas made fresh daily. From quick slices to full 18” pies, our menu is built for every craving.

NYC Pizza Made Fresh Daily — Slices from $4.99

East Village Pizza has been making classic New York–style pizza at 145 1st Avenue since 1997. Every slice starts with 72-hour cold-fermented dough, simple tomato sauce, and fresh mozzarella — made in-house every day, no exceptions.

Order by the slice for $4.99, build your own 18" whole pie, or try something from the menu that you won't find anywhere else: the double-stacked pizza, heart-shaped pies, and a full gluten-free menu.

Order online via Grubhub or call (212) 529-4545. Pickup and delivery available. Open until 3am Sun–Thu, 5am Fri–Sat.

Margherita

Pepperoni

Double Stacked

Heart Shaped

Order Online or In Store — Pickup & Delivery Available

All items available for pickup or delivery. Order through Grubhub or call us at (212) 529-4545. Walk-ins always welcome — slices ready to go all day.

Pizza by the Slice

New York–style slices made fresh throughout the day. Cheese from $4.99, specialty slices up to $6.89. Fold it, eat it standing — that's how it's done.

Cheese Slice

$4.99

Pepperoni Slice

$6.25

Buffalo Chicken Slice

$6.89

White Slice

$6.50

Sicilian Pepperoni Slice

$6.89

Baked Ziti Slice

Ziti-Ricotta-Tomato Sauce

$6.89

Extra Cheese Slice

$6.50

Margherita Slice

$6.89

BBQ Chicken Slice

$6.89

Sicilian Slice

$5.50

Mushroom Slice

$5.89

Vegetable Slice

Spinach-Broccoli-Mushroom-Tomatoes-Peppers-Olives

$6.89

Whole 18" Pizzas — Classic & Specialty Pies

All whole pies are 18 inches. Choose a classic like cheese ($25) or pepperoni ($27.99), go custom with Create Your Own ($25.92), or go big with the Combo Everything Pie ($35.35). Made to order, ready in minutes.

Cheese Pizza 18"

$25

Create Your Own Pizza 18"

Please See toppings list for add on toppings for customers to choose required toppings

$25.92

Buffalo Chicken Pizza 18"

$31.99

Sicilian Pie (One Size) 16"

$26.99

Pepperoni Jalapeno Pizza 18"

$30.99

Combo - Everything Pizza 18"

Pepperoni, Sausage, Meatballs, Mushroom, Spinach, Broccoli, Tomatoes, Peppers

$35.35

Vegetable Pizza 18"

Spinach-Broccoli-Mushroom-Tomatoes-Peppers-Olives

$31.99

Mushroom Pizza 18"

$27.99

Baked Ziti 18"

Pizza Ziti-Ricotta-Tomato Sauce

$30.99

Extra Cheese Pizza 18"

$27.99

Margherita Pizza 18"

$31.99

Pepperoni (Beef) Pizza 18"

$27.99

BBQ Chicken Pizza 18"

$32.99

Sicilian Pepperoni Pie (One Size) 16"

$29

White Pizza 18"

Two kinds of mozzarella cheese, ricotta cheese and pecorino Romano

$27.99

Meat Lover Pizza 18"

Pepperoni-Sausage-Meatballs

$33.11

Pepperoni Sausage Pizza 18"

$30.99

Pepperoni Mushroom Pizza 18"

$30.99

The Double-Stacked Pizza — An East Village Original

Two full 18-inch New York pizzas, baked stacked on top of each other. One inside topping, one outside topping. The double-stacked pizza started here — it's not a gimmick, it's a full two pies worth of pizza in one order. Available in a combination of Buffalo Chicken, Pepperoni, Cheese, Baked Ziti, Pepperoni & Jalapeño, BBQ Chicken, and Margherita. $46 for the whole stack.

Double Stacked Pizza 18"

Two full 18″ New York pizzas baked on top of each other. One inside topping, one outside topping. Inside: Buffalo Chicken, Pepperoni, Cheese, Baked Ziti, Pepperoni & Jalapeño, BBQ Chicken. Outside: Pepperoni & Jalapeño, Pepperoni, Cheese, Margherita.

$46

Heart-Shaped Pizza NYC — Available Year-Round

East Village Pizza has been making heart-shaped pizzas since 1997. Available in Cheese ($27.99), White ($29.99), Pepperoni ($29.99), and Margherita ($31.99). Popular for Valentine's Day, anniversaries, and birthdays — but you don't need a reason. Order ahead by calling (212) 529-4545.

Cheese

$27.99

White

$29.99

Pepperoni

$29.99

Margherita

$31.99

Sicilian Square Pizza

Thick-crust Sicilian pies made in a square pan — crispy bottom, airy inside. Available in Cheese, Margherita, Buffalo Chicken, White, Pepperoni, Meat Lovers, or Create Your Own. One size.

Sicilian Cheese Pizza

$26.99

Sicilian Margherita Pizza

$31.99

Sicilian Buffalo Chicken Pizza

$31.99

Sicilian White Pizza

$29

Sicilian Pepperoni Pizza

$29.99

Sicilian Meat Lovers Pizza

$31.99

Create Your Own Sicilian Pizza

$26.99

Gluten-Free Pizza — Full 12" Menu

We offer a full gluten-free pizza menu on a 12" crust. Available in Cheese, Margherita, White, Vegetable, Mushroom, Olives, and Create Your Own. Prices from $15.99. Important: Our kitchen is not a certified gluten-free facility. If you have Celiac disease, please do not order — cross-contamination is possible. These options are suitable for gluten sensitivity, not Celiac.

Gluten Free Cheese Pizza 12"

If you are CELIAC, please do not order since we are not fully gluten free.

$15.99

Gluten free

Create Your Own Gluten Free Pizza 12"

Please See toppings list for add on toppings for customers to choose required toppings.

$15.99

Gluten free

Gluten Free Olives Pizza 12"

If you are CELIAC, please do not order since we are not fully gluten free.

$19.99

Gluten free

Gluten Free White Pizza 12"

If you are CELIAC, please do not order since we are not fully gluten free.

$20

Gluten free

Gluten Free Vegetable Pizza 12"

If you are CELIAC, please do not order since we are not fully gluten free.

$24.99

Gluten free

Gluten Free Margherita Pizza 12"

If you are CELIAC, please do not order since we are not fully gluten free.

$24.99

Gluten free

Gluten Free Mushroom Pizza 12"

If you are CELIAC, please do not order since we are not fully gluten free.

$20

Gluten free

Calzones

Handmade calzones and mozzarella rolls, baked fresh. Create your own or choose from Buffalo Chicken, BBQ Chicken, Pepperoni, Meatball, Chicken, and more. Calzones from $15, mozzarella rolls from $15.

Create Your Own

Please See toppings list to add on toppings for customers to choose required toppings

$15

BBQ Chicken

$16.99

Chicken

$15

Cheese

$15

Pepperoni

$16.99

Buffalo Chicken

$16.99

Meatball

$16.99

Mozzarella Rolls

Create Your Own Roll

Please See toppings list to add on toppings for customers to choose required toppings

$15

Pepperoni Mozzarella Roll

$16.99

BBQ Chicken & Mozzarella Roll

$17.99

Broccoli & Mozzarella Roll

$15.99

Chicken & Mozzarella Roll

$16.99

Buffalo Chicken & Mozzarella Roll

$17.99

Sausage & Mozzarella Roll

$16.99

Spinach & Mozzarella Roll

$15.99

Garlic Knots, Sides & Cheesy Extras

Garlic knots by the half-dozen for $4.50, or go cheesy with triple-cheese garlic knot parm ($16). Meatballs, tiramisu, cheesecake, and all your drinks.

Cheesy Garlic Knots

Triple cheese, marinara, 6 pieces. As seen on Instagram.

$13

Cheesy Calzone

$18

Cheesy Meatball Parm

6 pieces meatballs marinara sauce and triple cheese as seen on Instagram. No dipping sauce

$17

Cheesy Garlic Knots Parm

6 pieces garlic knots marinara sauce and triple cheese as seen on Instagram

$16

Cheesy Garlic Knots Parm with Pepperoni

6 pieces garlic knots marinara sauce triple cheese and pepperoni as seen on Instagram

$18

Toppings

Toppings prices for Calzones,Rolls $1. Less From the small topping prices. All comes one size Only. For Gluten Free Pizzas, use small 16" topping Only

Extra Cheese

18" Pizza

Rolls&Calzones

Slices

Mushroom

18" Pizza

Rolls&Calzones

Slices

Buffalo Chicken

Not for gluten-free pizza

18" Pizza

Rolls&Calzones

Slices

Garlic

18" Pizza

$3.50

Rolls&Calzones

Slices

Meatballs

Not for gluten free pizza

18" Pizza

$4.50

Rolls&Calzones

$3.50

Slices

Olives

18" Pizza

$3.50

Rolls&Calzones

Slices

Peppers

18" Pizza

$3.50

Rolls&Calzones

Slices

Spinach

18" Pizza

$3.50

Rolls&Calzones

Slices

Ziti

Not for gluten free pizza

18" Pizza

$3.50

Rolls&Calzones

$2.50

Slices

Pepperoni

18" Pizza

Rolls&Calzones

Slices

Jalapeno

18" Pizza

Rolls&Calzones

Slices

BBQ Chicken

Not for gluten free pizza

18" Pizza

Rolls&Calzones

Slices

Chicken

Not for gluten free pizza

18" Pizza

Rolls&Calzones

Slices

Broccoli

18" Pizza

$3.50

Rolls&Calzones

Slices

Onions

18" Pizza

$3.50

Rolls&Calzones

Slices

Sausage

18" Pizza

Rolls&Calzones

Slices

Ricotta

18" Pizza

Rolls&Calzones

Slices

Side Orders

Extra sauces – Marinara Sauce, Ranch, Blue cheese $1.00

Garlic Knots (6 pieces)

Choose a dipping sauces: Marinara Sauce, Ranch, Blue cheese

$4.50

Meatballs (6 pieces)

$8.99

Desserts

Tiramisu

Cheesecake

SAUCE AND DRESSING (2 OZ.)

Each sauce or dressing Extra $1.75

Blue Cheese

$1.75

Ranch

$1.75

Marinara

$1.75

Beverages

Bottled Water

Poland Spring

$1.98

Gatorade

Orange

$3.35

Ripted Rush

$3.35

Cool Blue

$3.35

Lemon Lime

$3.35

Canned Soda

Coke

$2.25

Diet Coke

$2.25

Sprite

$2.25

Fanta

$2.25

Seltzer Water

$2.25

Ginger Ale

$2.25

Root Beer

$2.25

Snapple

Lemon Iced Tea

$3.25

Diet Lemon Iced Tea

$3.25

Peach Tea

$3.25

Diet Peach Tea

$3.25

Order East Village Pizza Tonight

Pickup and delivery available daily. Order online through Grubhub or call (212) 529-4545 — we'll have it ready. Walk-ins welcome any time we're open.

Hours: Sun–Thu 11am–3am · Fri–Sat 11am–5am
Address: 145 1st Ave, East Village, New York, NY 10003

Menu FAQ

What's the most popular pizza at East Village Pizza?

The classic cheese slice ($4.99) and the double-stacked pizza ($46) are the two most ordered items. The double-stacked pizza — two full 18" pies baked on top of each other — is an East Village original.

Do you have gluten-free options?

Yes — we offer a full 12" gluten-free pizza menu from $15.99. Note: our kitchen is not Celiac-certified. Suitable for gluten sensitivity only.

How big are your whole pizzas?

All whole pies are 18 inches. Sicilian pies are 16 inches, square-cut. Gluten-free pies are 12 inches.

Can I customize my pizza?

Yes — the Create Your Own 18" starts at $25.92 with toppings added from $3.50. Gluten-free create-your-own is $15.99.

What time does the kitchen close?

We serve food until close — 3am Sun–Thu and 5am Fri–Sat. Same menu all day and night.